
Day 3 — September 13
Why They See Us as Targets
Day 3 — September 13
Why They See Us as Targets
There's a real doctrine dividing humanity into “us” and “fair game.” Once you see it, the pattern of who gets targeted stops looking random.
9/11 was driven by a specific idea: that non-Muslims are, by default, legitimate targets — not accidentally, not as collateral damage, but deserving of death as a matter of a hardline religious teaching. That idea was largely left out of the post-9/11 conversation. It cut too close to an uncomfortable question, and most analysts and journalists avoided rather than explained it.
This day proposes an uncomfortable exercise: really try to see the world the way the most extreme, supremacist voices in this movement see it. Not to sympathize with them — but to understand clearly enough to recognize the pattern when it shows up again. In the harshest version of this worldview, non-believers aren't neutral bystanders. They're inferior by definition, and their only real options are conversion, subjugation, or death.
That's an uncomfortable thing to sit with. But avoiding it hasn't made anyone safer — it's mostly just left people unable to explain, even to themselves, why certain communities keep getting targeted over and over. Naming the worldview clearly is the first step toward recognizing when it's operating.
This exercise isn't really about any one religion's core teachings — many people who share that faith reject this reading. It's about a specific, hardline current within it that has, for decades, treated the label 'infidel' as license for violence. Understanding that doesn't require hostility toward ordinary believers. It requires being honest about what a committed and dangerous movement actually says — and does.
Sources
- Glossary: kafir, takfir, dar al-Islam, dar al-harb, dhimma, da'wa, al-walā' wa-l-barā', hijra, taqiyya
- Paul Berman, Terror and Liberalism (on Sayyid Qutb)
- Bat Ye'or, “Islam and Dhimmitude,” Middle East Quarterly, 2002
- “Bat Ye'or on Dhimmitude: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective,” MEF Podcast, 2025
- “Middle East Forum Launches Dhimmitude Institute,” MEF press release, 2025
- Tom Nisani, “Neo-Dhimmitude on Jerusalem's Temple Mount: A Case Study,” MEF Dhimmitude Project, 2026
- Mark Durie, “The Dhimmitude of the West: A New Trajectory?,” Middle East Forum, 2021
- Raymond Ibrahim, “Islamic Jizya: Fact and Fiction,” Middle East Forum, 2015
- Michael Scheuer, Through Our Enemies' Eyes: Osama bin Laden, Radical Islam, and the Future of America (Potomac Books, 2006)
